10 December 2025
St. Athanasius
Lutheran Church
Advent 2 Midweek Vienna, VA
“Judgment of the Forgiven”
Text:
Romans 5:1-11; Matthew 25:21-46
In the Name of (+) Jesus. Amen.
Judgement Day! What’s it going to be like?
A pastor friend of mine once told me he has a file
for every member of his congregation, so when Jesus comes again, he will be
able to say how he cared for each and every one. Is that what it’s going to
be like? Like an inquisition? I’m not sure I can do that . . .
Then a while back, my sister also sent me a story
she saw on the internet about Judgment Day - you probably know how it goes. You’ve
probably heard a similar thing . . . There’s the eternal courtroom .
. . God is the Judge, the devil is the prosecutor, and Jesus is your defense
attorney. And you’re on trial. The devil then goes through every sin you’ve
ever committed - every one of your sinful thoughts and words and deeds
and desires! Then ones you knew and the ones you didn’t. The ones you remember
and the ones you’ve forgotten. He goes through them all - all the reasons you
should be condemned. And he’s right, of course. . . . But when he’s done, Jesus
stands up and says: But I died for all those sins. This one is mine. . .
. Then the Judge says not guilty, and in you go.
I’m not sure I want that. No, I’m sure I don’t!
I don’t want all my sins dredged up and rehearsed for me! And who else will be
there? Who else gets to hear? EGADS! Is that what it’s going to be like?
Well, let’s think about this a little tonight . . .
First, I would point you to the Psalm we sang. It
said: as far as the east is from the west, so far does he remove our
transgressions from us. Do you know how far that is? Some of you have
heard me talk about this before, but I think it’s worth repeating, and
especially as we think about the Last Day and judgment. How far is the east
from the west? Well, to think about that, think about why God said as far
as the east is from the west and not as far as the north is
from the south. Do you know why? Because north and south meet.
Imagine you’re flying around the globe, up toward the north pole . . . There is
a point where you stop flying north and start
flying south. There’s a point they meet. But now imagine you’re flying
around the equator . . . There is never a time you stop flying
east and start flying west. East and west never meet like
north and south do. Now the important part of that is: what does that mean
for your sins? If they are separated from you as far as the east is from
the west . . . are they coming back to haunt you on the Last Day?
And then there is the Catechism we reviewed. In
those words we said that we receive absolution, that is, forgiveness, from
the pastor as from God Himself, not doubting but firmly believing
that by it our sins are forgiven - not just here on earth - but
before God in heaven. And then there was also this: that when the
called ministers of Christ . . . absolve those who repent of their sins . . . this
is just as valid and certain, even in heaven, as if Christ our dear Lord
dealt with us Himself. And then there was this promise, too: If
you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven. They are
gone. Even on the Last Day.
And then we heard the Scripture from Matthew -
about when the Son of Man comes in His glory, and how Judgement Day is going to
go . . . you’ve heard that Scripture before. But ask yourself this: were the
sins of the sheep brought up? They weren’t, were they? And what were the
sheep called? You who are blessed by my Father. And all that was
mentioned were the good deeds they did, which they even didn’t even realize!
So Psalm, Catechism, Scripture . . . these all
together are saying that when you hear the words of absolution every Sunday - I
forgive you all your sins - you can be sure they are!
The verdict you hear every Sunday is the same one you will hear on the Last
Day. Or maybe better to say, God doesn’t want you to wait and wonder what that
verdict on the Last Day will be - so He has it spoken to you now. You
are not guilty. You are forgiven. And you can take God at His Word.
And this (among other things) is what separates
Christians from people of other religions, like Muslims. They can do everything
God tells them to do, perfectly, and they still don’t know and can’t
be sure that God will be merciful to them in the end. They just have to hope.
But not us! Your sins are gone. Atoned for.
Remitted. Forgiven. They’re not. coming. back. If you can’t make east and west
meet, if you can’t put Jesus back in the tomb, then your sins aren’t coming
back either. Not now, not ever. You don’t have to fear Judgment Day because
of Jesus.
Which is what Paul was telling the Romans in that
Scripture we also heard tonight. We have been justified by faith . . . we
have been justified by His blood . . . we have been reconciled through our Lord
Jesus Christ. That’s all been done and given to you. Gifts of God,
received by grace through faith. Through the Word spoken and proclaimed to us,
the water poured on us, and the Supper fed to us. Gifts to give us life and
confidence and a sure and certain hope.
So based on all that . . . that story I mentioned
earlier . . . here’s how it really goes . . .
There’s the same set up . . . the eternal courtroom
. . . God is the Judge, the devil is the prosecutor, and Jesus is your defense
attorney. And you’re on trial. The devil gets out your book, your record book
with all your sins. And I know you - it’s a BIG one! And he smugly smiles and
opens it up, all ready to accuse you . . . every sin you’ve ever committed -
every sinful thought and word and deed and desire! The ones you knew and the
ones you didn’t. The ones you remember
and the ones you’ve forgotten. He’s ready to go through them all - all
the reasons you should be condemned. But instead of a presentation of all your
sins, there is . . . silence. Well, not exactly. You can hear the
pages turning, flipping, one after the other. And now the Judge is waiting,
losing patience. Well Mr. Devil, what have you got? They . . . they were
here before! All his sins! I know they were! But now, all there is . . . are
blood stains. And now it’s Jesus’ turn to smile. And with nothing to accuse
you with, you are free.
You see, Judgment Day already happened for you.
On the cross. And that blood wiped out all your sins. So on the Last Day, you
have nothing to fear. Go in peace.
In the Name of the Father, and of the (+) Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.